Mr. Kevin Rudd
Prime Minister of Australia
postmaster@pmc.gov.au
Dear Prime Minister,
We refer to the reports below for your information and action.
Former chief justice of the Family Court of Australia Alastair Nicholson is to be congratulated for raising his concern that you have broken your promise in restoring the Racial Discrimination Act and the miss-treatment of the original owners of this land.
We have also written to you on a number of occasions with regard to this immoral racial discrimination against indigenous Australians but you preferred to ignore our warnings.
Would you like to comment about professor Nicholson's report, please?
Yours respectfully,
Eddie Hwang
President
Unity Party WA
UnityPartyWA@westnet.com.au
http://twitter.com/unitywa (Uploaded)
http://unitypartywa.blogspot.com/
www.unitywa.org
Ph/Fax: 61 893681884
Date: 10-Feb-2010.
Environmental Friendly - Save the trees - Use Email.
Can you afford to give Telstra/Bigpond a try?
Income program a cloak for racism: professor
ADELE HORIN - February 10, 2010
THE federal government's plan to extend income management of welfare payments beyond the Northern Territory is a ''clumsily disguised and cynical attempt'' to perpetuate racial discrimination against indigenous Australians, a former chief justice of the Family Court of Australia said yesterday.
Alastair Nicholson, now an honorary professorial fellow in law at the University of Melbourne, said he considered it ''highly unlikely'' the proposed powers would ever be used against welfare recipients generally.
''The real targets of the income management scheme are likely to be Aboriginal people, including Aboriginal people living beyond the Northern Territory.''
Professor Nicholson was speaking at the launch in Melbourne of the book This Is What We Said, which contains accounts from Aborigines affected by the Northern Territory emergency intervention. The measures were introduced by the Howard government in 2007 and nullified the Racial Discrimination Act in the affected communities.
In strong criticism of the Rudd government, which had promised to restore the Racial Discrimination Act, Professor Nicholson said its proposed legislation perpetuated the discrimination.
He said an analysis showed Aboriginal people already subject to income management would continue to be so for a further 12 months after the proposed law came into effect.
''For these people, who include most of the Aboriginal population of the Northern Territory, it is as if the repeal of the RDA … never happened.''
As well, the ''purported'' extension of income management beyond the Northern Territory and to other groups was ''little more than a ruse to overcome the provisions of the RDA''.
The Minister for Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs, Jenny Macklin, said: ''Income management is delivering benefits across the country for indigenous and non-indigenous Australians, including increased school attendance in some Cape York communities, people spending more on food, including fresh fruit and vegetables, in the Northern Territory, and an increase in the number of families being referred for income management by child protection authorities in metropolitan Perth.''
She said that as part of the government's welfare changes, non-discriminatory income management would be be introduced first in the Northern Territory, and after evaluation, to vulnerable communities across Australia.
Under the plan long-term welfare recipients, including sole parents and young people who live in areas designated as ''disadvantaged'', will have 50-70 per cent of their allowance quarantined to be spent on designated items in specified shops.
Professor Nicholson said the measure would punish welfare recipients as a class, and was a ''sloppy, cheap and unfair solution'' that reflected lazy politics. It showed how far the government was prepared to go to maintain its income management regime.
However, though income management would be applicable throughout Australia, it was clear the criteria in the bill were designed in such a way as ''to target Aboriginal people without expressly saying so'' and might now encompass others as well.
Aboriginal health 'world's worst'
April 02, 2007 07:08am - Perthnow
AUSTRALIA has been ranked at the bottom of a league table of wealthy nations working to improve the health of its indigenous people.
The report, report to be published today by the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) and Oxfam Australia, found New Zealand, Canada and the US had narrowed the life expectancy gap between non-indigenous and indigenous people to approximately seven years.
But in Australia, Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders are still dying nearly 20-years younger than non-Aboriginal Australians.
Oxfam said Australia lagged behind other wealthy nations in redressing the imbalance in indigenous health on a range of fronts.
The aid agency said Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander infant mortality rates were more than 50 per cent higher than for indigenous children in the USA and New Zealand.
Low birth weights were also more than double the incidence of those of indigenous populations in Canada and the US, as well as 60 per cent higher than in New Zealand's indigenous population.
Executive Director of Oxfam Australia, Andrew Hewett, said the health indicators were a national scandal.
"At what point do we stand up and start shouting?" he said.
"It's scandalous that in a country as wealthy as Australia we cannot solve a health crisis affecting less than three-per cent of the population."
Oxfam said federal and state governments needed to invest an extra $350 million to $500 million each year into primary health care for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people to correct the slide.
White man's rule, black man's injustice
April 6, 2007 - smh
A death in a remote town in the Northern Territory has exposed faultlines in the justice system, writes Lindsay Murdoch.
White man's justice meant nothing in Wadeye as fists, rocks, sticks and hammers flew, spilling blood into the outback's red dust on a scorching hot afternoon. It was payback time. By mid-afternoon almost 300 people had gathered at a football oval in one of Australia's most isolated communities, for a fight between two clan-based gangs.
Detective Senior Constable Carmen Butcher knew she would not be able to stop the brutality when she and two other officers went to the oval, because for centuries this was the way Aboriginal people had settled their disputes here, 350 kilometres south-west of Darwin.
"Generally when something happens in the community they tend to try and sort it out themselves by fighting, and usually if they have a large fight there's nothing we can do about it," Butcher said later.
But nobody counted on the actions of the former Pauline Hanson supporter Robert Whittington, a newcomer to Wadeye, who also went to the oval that October day in 2002. The acting sergeant-in-charge of Wadeye's police station raised his pistol and fired at least four shots in quick succession, killing 18-year-old Robert Jongmin and wounding another youth, witnesses said.
Moments later, Butcher confronted Jongmin's father, Ambrose, who was armed with a wheel brace and hammer. "I stopped him and spoke to him and just said to him that it's not the way … get rid of the weapons and let the police deal with it," Butcher told him.
Jongmin, 54, listened. But the respected clan leader now says his decision to turn his back on his people's traditional payback, which includes spearings, and allow white man's law to deliver justice for his son's killing was a mistake that ruined his life. Jongmin says his son had never been in trouble with police, unlike many local youths, and that he was a hero because he ran onto the oval to wrestle a shotgun from a youth who was threatening to shoot people. Whittington opened fire after the shotgun discharged into the ground, witnesses said. "Look at what happened … my son [did that] and was shot in the back by a policeman," Jongmin says.
Jongmin wants the Northern Territory Government to set up an independent inquiry into the way police and lawyers handled the shooting after Whittington walked free, even though a magistrate had found a prima face case for murder after hearing weeks of evidence. He also wants the Northern Territory Government to pass retrospective legislation so that Whittington can face new charges.
Whittington was supposed to stand trial last year after the Director of Public Prosecutions' office reduced the murder charge to committing a dangerous act causing death. But just as a jury was about to start hearing evidence, the trial judge, Dean Mildren, noticed what the bevy of case lawyers had not. Whittington had not been charged with an offence within two months of the shooting. He dismissed the charge.
Lawyers say the territory's justice system failed the Jongmin family and Wadeye, a long-troubled community struggling to end the gang violence that last year turned its streets into a war zone. Other serious criminal charges hung over Whittington, who was suspended on full pay, for 4½ years although he could have been dismissed for breaching the Police Administration Act in 2002.
Jongmin can't look at photographs of Robert, his youngest son. He can't speak his name. "My life was ruined. I am slowly trying to pick myself up," he says.
Jongmin says the police should have kept away from payback business "like they had done over all the years". "A policeman is here for five minutes - bang, bang, bang."
Jongmin says he has not received an apology for the death of his son. "How can they do that with what he [Whittington] done … face to face with me. I don't think so," he says. "What's the use of an apology from a white man? My son is gone. He should be here with us now."
Since the shooting, the police have ordered residents not to use traditional payback violence to settle disputes and have adopted a zero-tolerance policy towards inter-clan violence. But the dismissal of charges against Whittington has undermined these efforts. At least one clan leader offered to be speared to settle lingering problems between the two gangs over Robert Jongmin's death.
Sean Bowden, a Darwin lawyer representing Jongmin, says there are aspects of the case the family wants independently investigated. "The family is seeking justice and to obtain justice the family feels that Mr Whittington should face a jury on the charges that were brought against him," Bowden says.
In a letter to Jongmin last month, the Director of Public Prosecutions, Richard Coates, said there was evidence Whittington "should not have fired his pistol when he did". Coates said Whittington had said in an unreleased statement he thought when he fired the pistol the wounded youth, Tobias Worumbu, had shot Robert Jongmin "and that was why he fired his pistol at Mr Worumbu".
The Jongmin family last month asked Coates to appeal the dismissal of the charge against Whittington to the High Court. Coates did not reply to the request before the time limit for the appeal to be lodged had expired.
Whittington, whose legal costs have been paid by the NT Government, is back on duty in Darwin. An inquest into Robert Jongmin's death has been set for August 7, and the Jongmin family will co-operate.
Wednesday, February 10, 2010
Monday, February 1, 2010
Thank you for your email, Mr. Hwang
----- Original Message -----
From: Rudd, Kevin (MP)
To: Unity Party WA
Sent: 16 March, 2007 1:17 PM
Subject: RE: Disgraceful security pact
Dear Mr Hwang
Thank you for your email of support and for sending me the report. This year will bring many
challenges and I look forward very much to your continued support as we work towards the election
of a Federal Labor Government.
Thank you once again for taking the time to drop me a line.
Kind regards,
Kevin Rudd
Federal Labor Leader
Member for Griffith
From: Rudd, Kevin (MP)
To: Unity Party WA
Sent: 16 March, 2007 1:17 PM
Subject: RE: Disgraceful security pact
Dear Mr Hwang
Thank you for your email of support and for sending me the report. This year will bring many
challenges and I look forward very much to your continued support as we work towards the election
of a Federal Labor Government.
Thank you once again for taking the time to drop me a line.
Kind regards,
Kevin Rudd
Federal Labor Leader
Member for Griffith
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Obama to control greedy banks
Mr. Barack Obama,
President of the US,
president@whitehouse.gov
Dear President,
We refer to the report below for your information and wish to congratulate you for taken this drastic action which is long overdue.
The global greedy banking cartel and other financial institutions are there to serve their own interests and must be controlled as to avoid another Great Depression!!
Yours respectfully,
Eddie Hwang
President
Unity Party WA
UnityPartyWA@westnet.com.au
http://unitypartywa.blogspot.com/
www.unitywa.org
Ph/Fax: 61 893681884
Date: 23-Jan-2010.
Environmental Friendly - Save the trees - Use Email.
Can you afford to give Bigpond a try?
Obama plan to limit the size of banks - report
From: AFP - January 21, 2010 4:24PM
US President Barack Obama will tonight propose new limits on the size of US banks after spending billions of tax-payer dollars to bail out "too-big-to-fail'' firms, a senior official says.
The measures would place sweeping new restrictions on a sector seen as responsible for sparking the largest recession since the Great Depression of the 1930s.
"A couple of months ago the President began discussing with his economic team the need to include in financial reform more specific and stronger provisions to limit the size and scope of financial institutions'' the official said.
The proposals aim "to cut down on excessive risk taking'' among the largest banks, after crises at a handful of the largest firms threatened to choke the flow of cash to the US economy.
''The President will announce a series of measures that address size and scope'' of the institutions the official said.
by efforts to rescue banks that were exposed to massive loses on the sub-prime mortgage market.
The official, who asked not to be named, said the new measures would limit banks' ability to use their own cash to buy such financial instruments, so-called proprietary trading.
"The proposal will include size and complexity limits specifically on proprietary trading,'' the source said.
Facing widespread voter anger over state take-overs of the troubled firms, Mr Obama earlier this month proposed a tax on big banks and warned the banking industry not to block or water down his planned regulatory reforms.
"It is both in the country's interests and ultimately in the financial industry's interest to have updated rules of the road to prevent abuse and excess.''
The new measures will have to be approved by Congress before becoming law.
President of the US,
president@whitehouse.gov
Dear President,
We refer to the report below for your information and wish to congratulate you for taken this drastic action which is long overdue.
The global greedy banking cartel and other financial institutions are there to serve their own interests and must be controlled as to avoid another Great Depression!!
Yours respectfully,
Eddie Hwang
President
Unity Party WA
UnityPartyWA@westnet.com.au
http://unitypartywa.blogspot.com/
www.unitywa.org
Ph/Fax: 61 893681884
Date: 23-Jan-2010.
Environmental Friendly - Save the trees - Use Email.
Can you afford to give Bigpond a try?
Obama plan to limit the size of banks - report
From: AFP - January 21, 2010 4:24PM
US President Barack Obama will tonight propose new limits on the size of US banks after spending billions of tax-payer dollars to bail out "too-big-to-fail'' firms, a senior official says.
The measures would place sweeping new restrictions on a sector seen as responsible for sparking the largest recession since the Great Depression of the 1930s.
"A couple of months ago the President began discussing with his economic team the need to include in financial reform more specific and stronger provisions to limit the size and scope of financial institutions'' the official said.
The proposals aim "to cut down on excessive risk taking'' among the largest banks, after crises at a handful of the largest firms threatened to choke the flow of cash to the US economy.
''The President will announce a series of measures that address size and scope'' of the institutions the official said.
by efforts to rescue banks that were exposed to massive loses on the sub-prime mortgage market.
The official, who asked not to be named, said the new measures would limit banks' ability to use their own cash to buy such financial instruments, so-called proprietary trading.
"The proposal will include size and complexity limits specifically on proprietary trading,'' the source said.
Facing widespread voter anger over state take-overs of the troubled firms, Mr Obama earlier this month proposed a tax on big banks and warned the banking industry not to block or water down his planned regulatory reforms.
"It is both in the country's interests and ultimately in the financial industry's interest to have updated rules of the road to prevent abuse and excess.''
The new measures will have to be approved by Congress before becoming law.
Obama to control greedy banks
Mr. Barack Obama,
President of the US,
president@whitehouse.gov
Dear President,
We refer to the report below for your information and wish to congratulate you for taken this drastic action which is long overdue.
The global greedy banking cartel and other financial institutions are there to serve their own interests and must be controlled as to avoid another Great Depression!!
Yours respectfully,
Eddie Hwang
President
Unity Party WA
UnityPartyWA@westnet.com.au
http://unitypartywa.blogspot.com/
www.unitywa.org
Ph/Fax: 61 893681884
Date: 23-Jan-2010.
Environmental Friendly - Save the trees - Use Email.
Can you afford to give Bigpond a try?
Obama plan to limit the size of banks - report
From: AFP - January 21, 2010 4:24PM
US President Barack Obama will tonight propose new limits on the size of US banks after spending billions of tax-payer dollars to bail out "too-big-to-fail'' firms, a senior official says.
The measures would place sweeping new restrictions on a sector seen as responsible for sparking the largest recession since the Great Depression of the 1930s.
"A couple of months ago the President began discussing with his economic team the need to include in financial reform more specific and stronger provisions to limit the size and scope of financial institutions'' the official said.
The proposals aim "to cut down on excessive risk taking'' among the largest banks, after crises at a handful of the largest firms threatened to choke the flow of cash to the US economy.
''The President will announce a series of measures that address size and scope'' of the institutions the official said.
by efforts to rescue banks that were exposed to massive loses on the sub-prime mortgage market.
The official, who asked not to be named, said the new measures would limit banks' ability to use their own cash to buy such financial instruments, so-called proprietary trading.
"The proposal will include size and complexity limits specifically on proprietary trading,'' the source said.
Facing widespread voter anger over state take-overs of the troubled firms, Mr Obama earlier this month proposed a tax on big banks and warned the banking industry not to block or water down his planned regulatory reforms.
"It is both in the country's interests and ultimately in the financial industry's interest to have updated rules of the road to prevent abuse and excess.''
The new measures will have to be approved by Congress before becoming law.
President of the US,
president@whitehouse.gov
Dear President,
We refer to the report below for your information and wish to congratulate you for taken this drastic action which is long overdue.
The global greedy banking cartel and other financial institutions are there to serve their own interests and must be controlled as to avoid another Great Depression!!
Yours respectfully,
Eddie Hwang
President
Unity Party WA
UnityPartyWA@westnet.com.au
http://unitypartywa.blogspot.com/
www.unitywa.org
Ph/Fax: 61 893681884
Date: 23-Jan-2010.
Environmental Friendly - Save the trees - Use Email.
Can you afford to give Bigpond a try?
Obama plan to limit the size of banks - report
From: AFP - January 21, 2010 4:24PM
US President Barack Obama will tonight propose new limits on the size of US banks after spending billions of tax-payer dollars to bail out "too-big-to-fail'' firms, a senior official says.
The measures would place sweeping new restrictions on a sector seen as responsible for sparking the largest recession since the Great Depression of the 1930s.
"A couple of months ago the President began discussing with his economic team the need to include in financial reform more specific and stronger provisions to limit the size and scope of financial institutions'' the official said.
The proposals aim "to cut down on excessive risk taking'' among the largest banks, after crises at a handful of the largest firms threatened to choke the flow of cash to the US economy.
''The President will announce a series of measures that address size and scope'' of the institutions the official said.
by efforts to rescue banks that were exposed to massive loses on the sub-prime mortgage market.
The official, who asked not to be named, said the new measures would limit banks' ability to use their own cash to buy such financial instruments, so-called proprietary trading.
"The proposal will include size and complexity limits specifically on proprietary trading,'' the source said.
Facing widespread voter anger over state take-overs of the troubled firms, Mr Obama earlier this month proposed a tax on big banks and warned the banking industry not to block or water down his planned regulatory reforms.
"It is both in the country's interests and ultimately in the financial industry's interest to have updated rules of the road to prevent abuse and excess.''
The new measures will have to be approved by Congress before becoming law.
Yes, Mr. Gore, we will help to spread your call
Yes Mr. Gore, we will help to spread your call.
Eddie Hwang
----- Original Message -----
From: Al Gore, The We Campaign
To: Unity Party WA
Sent: Wednesday, September 10, 2008 3:35 AM
Subject: We have a choice
Call your members of Congress NOW to demand new, clean energy.
Take Action.
Dear eddie,
I need your help. Will you make a call?
Congress will consider energy legislation this week. Of course, the oil industry is pushing its "drill, drill" slogan with all its might -- and some are hoping to use this for political advantage.
Meanwhile, tax credits for investments in solar and wind power have not been extended, and the growing renewables business that just made America the largest producer of wind power in the world, is on the verge of shutting down huge planned projects all over the country.
Billions in private investment, thousands of megawatts of new, clean energy, and more than 100,000 new jobs expected for 2009 will be lost.
We face a stark choice: subsidize old, dirty energy or invest in new, clean energy. This should be easy, but the influence of the oil lobby is deep -- they've already spent more than $100 million in lobbying and advertising this year. Please call your members of Congress now and tell them to pass legislation that will Repower America.
Click here to find out how to call.
Washington is being diverted by all the political noise around "drill, drill" away from what really will make a difference -- building a new, clean energy future. Projects in the pipeline that will power millions of homes will be canceled, setting us back for years, if Congress doesn't do the right thing now. Congress needs to hear from all of us.
Click here to make a quick call today.
Thank you so much,
Al Gore
www.wecansolveit.org
Eddie Hwang
----- Original Message -----
From: Al Gore, The We Campaign
To: Unity Party WA
Sent: Wednesday, September 10, 2008 3:35 AM
Subject: We have a choice
Call your members of Congress NOW to demand new, clean energy.
Take Action.
Dear eddie,
I need your help. Will you make a call?
Congress will consider energy legislation this week. Of course, the oil industry is pushing its "drill, drill" slogan with all its might -- and some are hoping to use this for political advantage.
Meanwhile, tax credits for investments in solar and wind power have not been extended, and the growing renewables business that just made America the largest producer of wind power in the world, is on the verge of shutting down huge planned projects all over the country.
Billions in private investment, thousands of megawatts of new, clean energy, and more than 100,000 new jobs expected for 2009 will be lost.
We face a stark choice: subsidize old, dirty energy or invest in new, clean energy. This should be easy, but the influence of the oil lobby is deep -- they've already spent more than $100 million in lobbying and advertising this year. Please call your members of Congress now and tell them to pass legislation that will Repower America.
Click here to find out how to call.
Washington is being diverted by all the political noise around "drill, drill" away from what really will make a difference -- building a new, clean energy future. Projects in the pipeline that will power millions of homes will be canceled, setting us back for years, if Congress doesn't do the right thing now. Congress needs to hear from all of us.
Click here to make a quick call today.
Thank you so much,
Al Gore
www.wecansolveit.org
EU steel makers oppose BHP-Rio iron ore deal
Mr. Kevin Rudd,
Prime Minister of Australia
postmaster@pmc.gov.au
Dear Mr. Rudd,
We refer to the reports below for your information.
Since you ignored our email below, we will upload the various reports onto our website for our global readers
to judge whether our concern that important raw materials like iron ores should never be
monopolised by countries like Australia and Brazil who are well end owed with them, to the
detriment of the world economy as a whole.
We strongly believe that a sharing of these natural resources world-wide in accordance with time-tested economic principles
aimed at maximising production and the better utilization of the world's natural resources would bring about greater justice
to humankind.
Fair and equitable distribution of natural resources to nations which are not well-endowed with them would bring about a
world that is a better place to live in for all.
Australia - the lucky country needs to act responsibly.
Yours respectfully,
Eddie Hwang
www.unitywa.org
10-Nov-2009.
EU steel makers oppose BHP-Rio iron ore deal
EUROPEAN steel makers have called on European Union antitrust regulators to probe BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto's iron
ore jont venture in WA.
The European steel industry federation Eurofer - whose members include the world's biggest steel makers ArcelorMittal SA,
ThyssenKrupp AG and Corus Group - said the joint venture isn't "much different from the effects which would have
resulted" from BHP's takeover bid for Rio last year.
"The European steel industry continues to believe that a merger of iron ore assets of this type in a world market already
dominated by just three suppliers would not be in the interests of the steel industry, European consumers or the European
economy," it said.
EU opposition to BHP's hostile $US68 billion ($A86.04 billion) bid for rival Rio forced it to abandon the takeover attempt
last year.
The European Commission saw competition problems with the deal that they said could hike prices and reduce choice for
European mineral and metals customers.
Rio also complained that the bid undervalued it.
The two miners are now planning a joint production project to pool all their iron ore assets in Western Australia, a move
that could save them billions as iron ore prices slide.
Australia's BHP will also pay Rio $US5.8 billion ($A7.34 billion) to equalise its contribution to the joint venture.
The deal rescues Rio after it scrapped a $US19.5 billion ($A24.67 billion) deal with China's Chinalco over Australian fears
that the deal would give a foreign company a strategic stake in one of the country's biggest industries.
Rio's balance sheet is weighed down by $US38.7 billion ($A48.97 billion) in debt.
Combining BHP and Rio would allow them to
Prime Minister of Australia
postmaster@pmc.gov.au
Dear Mr. Rudd,
We refer to the reports below for your information.
Since you ignored our email below, we will upload the various reports onto our website for our global readers
to judge whether our concern that important raw materials like iron ores should never be
monopolised by countries like Australia and Brazil who are well end owed with them, to the
detriment of the world economy as a whole.
We strongly believe that a sharing of these natural resources world-wide in accordance with time-tested economic principles
aimed at maximising production and the better utilization of the world's natural resources would bring about greater justice
to humankind.
Fair and equitable distribution of natural resources to nations which are not well-endowed with them would bring about a
world that is a better place to live in for all.
Australia - the lucky country needs to act responsibly.
Yours respectfully,
Eddie Hwang
www.unitywa.org
10-Nov-2009.
EU steel makers oppose BHP-Rio iron ore deal
EUROPEAN steel makers have called on European Union antitrust regulators to probe BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto's iron
ore jont venture in WA.
The European steel industry federation Eurofer - whose members include the world's biggest steel makers ArcelorMittal SA,
ThyssenKrupp AG and Corus Group - said the joint venture isn't "much different from the effects which would have
resulted" from BHP's takeover bid for Rio last year.
"The European steel industry continues to believe that a merger of iron ore assets of this type in a world market already
dominated by just three suppliers would not be in the interests of the steel industry, European consumers or the European
economy," it said.
EU opposition to BHP's hostile $US68 billion ($A86.04 billion) bid for rival Rio forced it to abandon the takeover attempt
last year.
The European Commission saw competition problems with the deal that they said could hike prices and reduce choice for
European mineral and metals customers.
Rio also complained that the bid undervalued it.
The two miners are now planning a joint production project to pool all their iron ore assets in Western Australia, a move
that could save them billions as iron ore prices slide.
Australia's BHP will also pay Rio $US5.8 billion ($A7.34 billion) to equalise its contribution to the joint venture.
The deal rescues Rio after it scrapped a $US19.5 billion ($A24.67 billion) deal with China's Chinalco over Australian fears
that the deal would give a foreign company a strategic stake in one of the country's biggest industries.
Rio's balance sheet is weighed down by $US38.7 billion ($A48.97 billion) in debt.
Combining BHP and Rio would allow them to
Staring down the dragon
Mr. Don Argus,
Chairman - BHP
businessconduct@bhpbilliton.com
Dear Mr. Argus,
We refer to the report below for your information.
Would you like to comment, please?
We look forward to hearing from you in due course.
Yours sincerely,
Eddie Hwang
President
Unity Party WA
UnityPartyWA@westnet.com.au
http://twitter.com/unitywa
http://unitypartywa.blogspot.com/
www.unitywa.org
Ph/Fax: 61 893681884
Date: 30-Jan-2010.
Environmental Friendly - Save the trees - Use Email.
Can you afford to give Telstra/Bigpond a try?
Staring down the dragon: BHP's battles in China
January 30, 2010 - smh
BHP has stood up to China like no other corporation, but the world's biggest miner is playing a dangerous game, John Garnaut reports from Shanghai.
When BHP Billiton's chief executive, Marius Kloppers, flew to China last week, he was expected to reach out and try to placate officials who are overseeing iron ore negotiations and administering the country's new anti-monopoly laws.
Commentators expected he would see Shang Ming, the director-general of China's Anti-Monopoly Bureau at the Ministry of Commerce, who has spent much of the past eight months working out whether he can and will upset BHP's iron ore joint venture plans with Rio Tinto.
''Everyone knows that the Chinese Government, including the Ministry of Commerce, are extremely unhappy about the proposed joint venture,'' says Allan Fels, the former Australian competition boss, who has advised Shang on administering his new anti-monopoly powers. ''And the Chinese law appears to have full extra-territorial force, which seemingly fully covers the transaction.''
Some thought Kloppers might also try to see Li Yizhong, the former oil company chief who now runs a ''super ministry'' of industry and information technology. The ministry is overseeing this year's price negotiations and is drawing up new measures to track and potentially control iron ore imports, at a time when BHP is leading the charge to tear the old benchmark pricing system down.
''The international iron ore market is monopolised by the three leading miners,'' said a spokesman for the Ministry of Industry and
Information Technology on Thursday. ''We hope that they will bear in mind the long-term interests of the industry and friendly long-term co-operation with China. We're expecting a fair price.''
But Kloppers didn't see Shang Ming, Li Yizhong or, it seems, any other senior Government official. He didn't make it to Beijing, where the company no longer has an office.
Instead, sources say, Kloppers mostly let his key customers come to him at BHP's Shanghai headquarters, which is reeling from the exodus of three of the company's most experienced and respected executives.
The China branch's president, Clinton Dines, left the company in June, after two decades. Frank Xu, who close observers say ''owned'' government relations for the company, left in July. And now Robin Bordie, the company's key China economist, has told the company she's walking out as well.
BHP is well aware that it is one of the few companies in the world with the power to set terms with China. ''If you're going to play in this game, then you have got to play with the big boys, and they know that,'' the chairman, Don Argus, told reporters in October, brushing off problems that might arise if the joint venture with Rio Tinto caused hostility in China.
BHP's clear and uncompromising China strategy has plenty of admirers. But those same people warn that success depends entirely on execution. ''It's not against the rules to start a war when dealing with China,'' says the long-time China head of another major resources company (which does not sell Australian iron ore). ''But you cannot back down, and you absolutely cannot lose.''
Jim McGregor, the former chairman of the American Chamber of Commerce in China, warned in Time magazine last week that China is becoming an increasingly unpredictable and hostile environment for foreign companies. He says it makes sense for some companies to draw a strategic line in the sand, provided they are well prepared and know that what goes around may come around.
In the past two years Chinese companies and officials have demonstrated that gaining better terms on the iron ore trade is a national priority. They have thrown their weight around, but have so far had mixed success.
Chinalco rudely interrupted BHP's original takeover bid for Rio Tinto, which was later aborted. China's top intelligence agency tapped the phone and email traffic of Rio Tinto, then detained Stern Hu and three other members of Rio's sales team, initially treating the case as a threat to China's national security.
The China Iron and Steel Association and some government officials managed to temporarily block spot market shipments from both companies. Chinese steel mills walked away from contracts without apology when prices plunged during the financial crisis.
But, so far, the laws of supply and demand have proved too much for even the champions of ''China Inc'' to overcome.
China's iron ore imports rose an astonishing 42 per cent last year, to 630 million tonnes, while the rest of the world collapsed. It accounted for as much as 70 per cent of global seaborne trade.
Australian miners secured the lion's share of those extra shipments. Australia's global iron ore exports rose 17 per cent to 383 million tonnes, even as they fell to other major destination. Exports to China rose by 46 per cent, to 282 million tonnes - nearly three-quarters of Australia's total.
It seems both BHP and Rio Tinto can virtually do what they like for as long as China desperately needs their ore. It may be a different story when the market turns. Chinese companies with Government support are bringing forward that turning point by madly planting start-up mines around the world.
''It's pretty obvious that BHP have decided that playing hard ball with China is OK," says Arthur Kroeber, the principal at Beijing consultancy Dragonomics.
''The structure of the market here clearly favours them, because ore producers are highly consolidated and the domestic consumer base is highly fragmented, with no reasonable prospect of being tightly controlled. In that sense, it is a strategy that makes sense.''
However, he says the strategy makes sense now but might not look so good from the moment when the supply curve catches up with demand.
''Business and politics in China are even more closely intertwined here than in most other markets,'' he says.
''If you go out of your way to play very aggressively when conditions favour you, there is a likelihood that there will be reprisals of one kind or another when conditions go the other way.''
BHP headquarters is confident that the work of reading, engaging and anticipating China has not missed a beat.
''Our China office is as important to us today as it always was, given the significance of the China market,'' says a BHP spokeswoman, Samantha Evans.
But it will not be easy to make up for the loss of Clinton Dines, Frank Xu and Robin Bordie, and the closure of BHP Billiton's office in Beijing.
In two years BHP's China staff has been cut from about 100 to 70, including the dismantling of both its China exploration and Beijing Olympics sponsorship teams. Rio Tinto, in contrast, maintains about 130 staff in Beijing and Shanghai.
''BHP has now got no machinery at all for engaging with the Chinese Government, at a time when Australian corporate and political relations with China have never been shakier,'' says one source who has worked with BHP.
''Frank 'owned' all of the relationships with the Chinese government and media. Clinton was pretty well-known and liked by domestic and foreign media, and Robin was part of that cabinet.''
All three employees declined to talk about the reasons for their departure.
Dines, who has taken up consultancies and board directorships, hinted at differences with head office in a joint opinion article published this month in the Herald.
''One area where the big suppliers have some work to do is developing - or repairing - stable, long-term relationships," he wrote, together with an iron ore consultant, Philip Kirchlechner. ''It seems that many senior managers in the industry do not understand what a relationship is, in the East-Asian, Confucian context.''
Bordie, according to BHP's website, had brought the company ''invaluable ability to analyse the complex situation and rapid changes in China - our single-country market''. Her analysis of China's economic recovery last year is thought to have been more optimistic and therefore more right than public comments given throughout the year by Kloppers and Argus. She is joining the Noble commodities group in Hong Kong.
Xu has left BHP for the Barclays investment bank, in part because his family could not easily make the transition to Shanghai.
But maintaining his unrivalled relationships throughout the Chinese resources industry and bureaucracy was always going to be more difficult from Shanghai.
''If you call up someone like Xiong Bilin [in charge of industry and consolidation at the National Development and Reform Commission] he'll say, 'OK, I'm free, let's have dinner tonight,' " says a government relations veteran. ''You simply can't arrange things far enough in advance to get through the traffic and catch a plane from Shanghai.''
Rio Tinto's travails in China are well known and it has the bigger hole to clamber out of.
But Rio is now sharing the bad press with BHP. Reports of BHP lobbying against ''China Inc'' in Canberra have been embellished in the Chinese media, producing front-page headlines like ''BAD BOY BHP''.
This week that story mutated and again sprang back to life.
BHP's government and community relationships may not be what they were two years ago, but its commercial operations remain strong. Its steady march towards clear corporate strategic goals stands in contrast to Rio Tinto's three-year vacillations.
Rio Tinto's China operations are going through a rebuilding phase. The company's chief iron ore salesman, Stern Hu, is in jail, along with three members of Hu's sales team, while Hu's former right-hand man has retreated to the company's Singapore sales platform. Rio's China president, Tony Loo, has quit the company and headed for Las Vegas, and is yet to be replaced.
BHP's production report last week shows it continues to ruthlessly and persistently execute its five-year-long strategy to dismantle the benchmark contract pricing system. The existing system penalises Australia compared with other benchmark suppliers who carry higher freight costs, such as Brazil, and also privileges Indian and domestic Chinese suppliers, who get much higher prices on China's spot market.
In the second half of last year, BHP sold 46 per cent of shipments on ''short-term referencing pricing'', with the remainder sold on annual contract prices. The statement implies that a large majority of shipments to China were made at quarterly negotiated prices, index-based pricing or the spot market.
The significance of this lies well beyond the tens of millions of dollars BHP implicitly earned from its shipments last year that its competitors did not.
It appears to mean that by the end of March, a large number of BHP's customers will have accepted that they have rescinded on their long-term contracts - perhaps in exchange for BHP forgiving contractual non-performance during the financial crisis. At the same time, local analysts say, the company has been rapidly gaining new customers on non-benchmark terms.
BHP has gone halfway towards smashing the benchmark pricing system in its most important market, while its competitors have not. At the same time, some observers suggest BHP has quietly taken the lead on negotiating with Baosteel and the China Iron and Steel Association on this year's prices for remaining Chinese benchmark contracts.
Clearly, BHP's smart and well-regarded iron ore sales chief, Ben Williams, has been on top of his marketing job.
Williams, who has spent 20 years of the past 30 in China and speaks the local language fluently, has been elevated to China president. He has back-up from Lu Jianzhong, a sharp and affable technology and uranium expert who was formerly a diplomat at the United Nations. Lu has taken control of Chinese media relations.
But they have a power of work ahead.
Whatever the market mood - and in recent weeks it has sagged - China's efforts to get a better deal in iron ore are not about to stop.
''Iron ore is a core national interest for China,'' a senior official says.
Nobody knows how the next round of iron ore wars will be played out. Shang Ming at the Ministry of Commerce might rule that the BHP-Rio joint venture is anti-competitive. But it's not obvious that he has legal sanctions in his armoury that would hurt the miners more than Chinese mills.
''Because BHP Billiton has almost no assets in China and there appears to be very little grip that the Chinese Government can have on this offshore transaction,'' says Fels, the former chairman of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission.
In June, shortly after announcing the Rio Tinto joint venture, Kloppers dismissed the risk of Chinese or Japanese regulators intervening with the deal.
He said his company was ''just largely a seller of product into those markets, so we don't have any local businesses in China or Japan that would be affected by this''.
An adviser attached to China's Ministry of Commerce immediately begged to differ.
''According to China's anti-trust law, we can veto such a merger agreement if the concentration of overseas business operators will affect domestic market competition,'' said Ma Yu, a director of the Foreign Investment Department at the ministry's Academy of International Trade and Economic Co-operation. ''If the joint venture is set up regardless of China's opposition, the Government can also resort to trade sanctions against the two entities on future business transactions with China.''
Business and government veterans of the Australia-China relationship and iron ore trade are impressed at the strategic vision of Kloppers and his chairman, Don Argus. But they worry that the pair have underestimated China before and may be doing so again.
Chairman - BHP
businessconduct@bhpbilliton.com
Dear Mr. Argus,
We refer to the report below for your information.
Would you like to comment, please?
We look forward to hearing from you in due course.
Yours sincerely,
Eddie Hwang
President
Unity Party WA
UnityPartyWA@westnet.com.au
http://twitter.com/unitywa
http://unitypartywa.blogspot.com/
www.unitywa.org
Ph/Fax: 61 893681884
Date: 30-Jan-2010.
Environmental Friendly - Save the trees - Use Email.
Can you afford to give Telstra/Bigpond a try?
Staring down the dragon: BHP's battles in China
January 30, 2010 - smh
BHP has stood up to China like no other corporation, but the world's biggest miner is playing a dangerous game, John Garnaut reports from Shanghai.
When BHP Billiton's chief executive, Marius Kloppers, flew to China last week, he was expected to reach out and try to placate officials who are overseeing iron ore negotiations and administering the country's new anti-monopoly laws.
Commentators expected he would see Shang Ming, the director-general of China's Anti-Monopoly Bureau at the Ministry of Commerce, who has spent much of the past eight months working out whether he can and will upset BHP's iron ore joint venture plans with Rio Tinto.
''Everyone knows that the Chinese Government, including the Ministry of Commerce, are extremely unhappy about the proposed joint venture,'' says Allan Fels, the former Australian competition boss, who has advised Shang on administering his new anti-monopoly powers. ''And the Chinese law appears to have full extra-territorial force, which seemingly fully covers the transaction.''
Some thought Kloppers might also try to see Li Yizhong, the former oil company chief who now runs a ''super ministry'' of industry and information technology. The ministry is overseeing this year's price negotiations and is drawing up new measures to track and potentially control iron ore imports, at a time when BHP is leading the charge to tear the old benchmark pricing system down.
''The international iron ore market is monopolised by the three leading miners,'' said a spokesman for the Ministry of Industry and
Information Technology on Thursday. ''We hope that they will bear in mind the long-term interests of the industry and friendly long-term co-operation with China. We're expecting a fair price.''
But Kloppers didn't see Shang Ming, Li Yizhong or, it seems, any other senior Government official. He didn't make it to Beijing, where the company no longer has an office.
Instead, sources say, Kloppers mostly let his key customers come to him at BHP's Shanghai headquarters, which is reeling from the exodus of three of the company's most experienced and respected executives.
The China branch's president, Clinton Dines, left the company in June, after two decades. Frank Xu, who close observers say ''owned'' government relations for the company, left in July. And now Robin Bordie, the company's key China economist, has told the company she's walking out as well.
BHP is well aware that it is one of the few companies in the world with the power to set terms with China. ''If you're going to play in this game, then you have got to play with the big boys, and they know that,'' the chairman, Don Argus, told reporters in October, brushing off problems that might arise if the joint venture with Rio Tinto caused hostility in China.
BHP's clear and uncompromising China strategy has plenty of admirers. But those same people warn that success depends entirely on execution. ''It's not against the rules to start a war when dealing with China,'' says the long-time China head of another major resources company (which does not sell Australian iron ore). ''But you cannot back down, and you absolutely cannot lose.''
Jim McGregor, the former chairman of the American Chamber of Commerce in China, warned in Time magazine last week that China is becoming an increasingly unpredictable and hostile environment for foreign companies. He says it makes sense for some companies to draw a strategic line in the sand, provided they are well prepared and know that what goes around may come around.
In the past two years Chinese companies and officials have demonstrated that gaining better terms on the iron ore trade is a national priority. They have thrown their weight around, but have so far had mixed success.
Chinalco rudely interrupted BHP's original takeover bid for Rio Tinto, which was later aborted. China's top intelligence agency tapped the phone and email traffic of Rio Tinto, then detained Stern Hu and three other members of Rio's sales team, initially treating the case as a threat to China's national security.
The China Iron and Steel Association and some government officials managed to temporarily block spot market shipments from both companies. Chinese steel mills walked away from contracts without apology when prices plunged during the financial crisis.
But, so far, the laws of supply and demand have proved too much for even the champions of ''China Inc'' to overcome.
China's iron ore imports rose an astonishing 42 per cent last year, to 630 million tonnes, while the rest of the world collapsed. It accounted for as much as 70 per cent of global seaborne trade.
Australian miners secured the lion's share of those extra shipments. Australia's global iron ore exports rose 17 per cent to 383 million tonnes, even as they fell to other major destination. Exports to China rose by 46 per cent, to 282 million tonnes - nearly three-quarters of Australia's total.
It seems both BHP and Rio Tinto can virtually do what they like for as long as China desperately needs their ore. It may be a different story when the market turns. Chinese companies with Government support are bringing forward that turning point by madly planting start-up mines around the world.
''It's pretty obvious that BHP have decided that playing hard ball with China is OK," says Arthur Kroeber, the principal at Beijing consultancy Dragonomics.
''The structure of the market here clearly favours them, because ore producers are highly consolidated and the domestic consumer base is highly fragmented, with no reasonable prospect of being tightly controlled. In that sense, it is a strategy that makes sense.''
However, he says the strategy makes sense now but might not look so good from the moment when the supply curve catches up with demand.
''Business and politics in China are even more closely intertwined here than in most other markets,'' he says.
''If you go out of your way to play very aggressively when conditions favour you, there is a likelihood that there will be reprisals of one kind or another when conditions go the other way.''
BHP headquarters is confident that the work of reading, engaging and anticipating China has not missed a beat.
''Our China office is as important to us today as it always was, given the significance of the China market,'' says a BHP spokeswoman, Samantha Evans.
But it will not be easy to make up for the loss of Clinton Dines, Frank Xu and Robin Bordie, and the closure of BHP Billiton's office in Beijing.
In two years BHP's China staff has been cut from about 100 to 70, including the dismantling of both its China exploration and Beijing Olympics sponsorship teams. Rio Tinto, in contrast, maintains about 130 staff in Beijing and Shanghai.
''BHP has now got no machinery at all for engaging with the Chinese Government, at a time when Australian corporate and political relations with China have never been shakier,'' says one source who has worked with BHP.
''Frank 'owned' all of the relationships with the Chinese government and media. Clinton was pretty well-known and liked by domestic and foreign media, and Robin was part of that cabinet.''
All three employees declined to talk about the reasons for their departure.
Dines, who has taken up consultancies and board directorships, hinted at differences with head office in a joint opinion article published this month in the Herald.
''One area where the big suppliers have some work to do is developing - or repairing - stable, long-term relationships," he wrote, together with an iron ore consultant, Philip Kirchlechner. ''It seems that many senior managers in the industry do not understand what a relationship is, in the East-Asian, Confucian context.''
Bordie, according to BHP's website, had brought the company ''invaluable ability to analyse the complex situation and rapid changes in China - our single-country market''. Her analysis of China's economic recovery last year is thought to have been more optimistic and therefore more right than public comments given throughout the year by Kloppers and Argus. She is joining the Noble commodities group in Hong Kong.
Xu has left BHP for the Barclays investment bank, in part because his family could not easily make the transition to Shanghai.
But maintaining his unrivalled relationships throughout the Chinese resources industry and bureaucracy was always going to be more difficult from Shanghai.
''If you call up someone like Xiong Bilin [in charge of industry and consolidation at the National Development and Reform Commission] he'll say, 'OK, I'm free, let's have dinner tonight,' " says a government relations veteran. ''You simply can't arrange things far enough in advance to get through the traffic and catch a plane from Shanghai.''
Rio Tinto's travails in China are well known and it has the bigger hole to clamber out of.
But Rio is now sharing the bad press with BHP. Reports of BHP lobbying against ''China Inc'' in Canberra have been embellished in the Chinese media, producing front-page headlines like ''BAD BOY BHP''.
This week that story mutated and again sprang back to life.
BHP's government and community relationships may not be what they were two years ago, but its commercial operations remain strong. Its steady march towards clear corporate strategic goals stands in contrast to Rio Tinto's three-year vacillations.
Rio Tinto's China operations are going through a rebuilding phase. The company's chief iron ore salesman, Stern Hu, is in jail, along with three members of Hu's sales team, while Hu's former right-hand man has retreated to the company's Singapore sales platform. Rio's China president, Tony Loo, has quit the company and headed for Las Vegas, and is yet to be replaced.
BHP's production report last week shows it continues to ruthlessly and persistently execute its five-year-long strategy to dismantle the benchmark contract pricing system. The existing system penalises Australia compared with other benchmark suppliers who carry higher freight costs, such as Brazil, and also privileges Indian and domestic Chinese suppliers, who get much higher prices on China's spot market.
In the second half of last year, BHP sold 46 per cent of shipments on ''short-term referencing pricing'', with the remainder sold on annual contract prices. The statement implies that a large majority of shipments to China were made at quarterly negotiated prices, index-based pricing or the spot market.
The significance of this lies well beyond the tens of millions of dollars BHP implicitly earned from its shipments last year that its competitors did not.
It appears to mean that by the end of March, a large number of BHP's customers will have accepted that they have rescinded on their long-term contracts - perhaps in exchange for BHP forgiving contractual non-performance during the financial crisis. At the same time, local analysts say, the company has been rapidly gaining new customers on non-benchmark terms.
BHP has gone halfway towards smashing the benchmark pricing system in its most important market, while its competitors have not. At the same time, some observers suggest BHP has quietly taken the lead on negotiating with Baosteel and the China Iron and Steel Association on this year's prices for remaining Chinese benchmark contracts.
Clearly, BHP's smart and well-regarded iron ore sales chief, Ben Williams, has been on top of his marketing job.
Williams, who has spent 20 years of the past 30 in China and speaks the local language fluently, has been elevated to China president. He has back-up from Lu Jianzhong, a sharp and affable technology and uranium expert who was formerly a diplomat at the United Nations. Lu has taken control of Chinese media relations.
But they have a power of work ahead.
Whatever the market mood - and in recent weeks it has sagged - China's efforts to get a better deal in iron ore are not about to stop.
''Iron ore is a core national interest for China,'' a senior official says.
Nobody knows how the next round of iron ore wars will be played out. Shang Ming at the Ministry of Commerce might rule that the BHP-Rio joint venture is anti-competitive. But it's not obvious that he has legal sanctions in his armoury that would hurt the miners more than Chinese mills.
''Because BHP Billiton has almost no assets in China and there appears to be very little grip that the Chinese Government can have on this offshore transaction,'' says Fels, the former chairman of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission.
In June, shortly after announcing the Rio Tinto joint venture, Kloppers dismissed the risk of Chinese or Japanese regulators intervening with the deal.
He said his company was ''just largely a seller of product into those markets, so we don't have any local businesses in China or Japan that would be affected by this''.
An adviser attached to China's Ministry of Commerce immediately begged to differ.
''According to China's anti-trust law, we can veto such a merger agreement if the concentration of overseas business operators will affect domestic market competition,'' said Ma Yu, a director of the Foreign Investment Department at the ministry's Academy of International Trade and Economic Co-operation. ''If the joint venture is set up regardless of China's opposition, the Government can also resort to trade sanctions against the two entities on future business transactions with China.''
Business and government veterans of the Australia-China relationship and iron ore trade are impressed at the strategic vision of Kloppers and his chairman, Don Argus. But they worry that the pair have underestimated China before and may be doing so again.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
.bmp)